Our Restaurant

A casual, relaxing outdoor dining experience overlooking the beautiful Haynes Creek where you can see the old Florida and always view an abundance of wildlife. Entertainment Fri, Sat, Sun. We also offer boat mooring, RV sites and boat launch.

Our Menu

Our Menu

Smoked Fish Dip a tasty mixture of mahi & wahoo in a creamy spread, served with crackers  5.99

Fried Mushrooms lightly breaded deep fried served
with ranch 5.99

Southern Gator Bites tender pieces of marinated gator lightly breaded and deep fried  7.99                 

Basket of Fries a generous serving of crinkle cut fries 4.99

Onion Rings thick cut onion ring beer battered and deep fried 5.99

Cheese Sticks fried mozzarella served with marinara 5.99

Frog Legs Lightly breaded and and deep fried to perfection served with tarter or try them buffalo style 7.99

On the Lite Side

Caesar Salad Crisp romaine lettuce,croutons, parmesan cheese and our Caesar dressing tossed together  5.99

Add Chicken 3.00
Add Shrimp, Gator or Mahi 4.00

Chef Salad crisp lettuce, onions, peppers, tomatoes, shredded cheese, boiled egg then topped with ham and turkey and your choice of dressing 8.99

B.L.T Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo served on white or wheat toast 5.99

Turkey or Ham Club Triple decker sandwich topped with bacon,lettuce, tomato, mayo and 4oz of turkey or ham served on white or wheat toast 6.99


Onion rings 2.50
French fries 2.25
Side Caesar 2.25
Cole Slaw 1.50
Substitute Fries 1.50
Onion rings  1.99

Fish Nuggets alaskan pollock cut into pieces and lightly breaded, served with homemade tarter sauce 6.99                   

Fried Pickle Spears dill pickle spears lightly breaded and deep fried and served with homemade horseradish sauce 6.99

Gator Bay Crab Cake delicious crab cake served with a homemade cajun remoulade sauce 4.99

Flying Shrimp lightly hand breaded shrimp fried to perfection or try them buffalo style 7.99
(Garlic/Parm add 1.00)

Corn Fritters spicy jalapeno and sweet corn mixture battered and deep fried served with ranch 5.99

Bay Burgers

Our burgers are 8oz fresh ground beef and served with chips. Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, mayo upon request

Reuben Burger grilled your way with sauerkraut, swiss cheese and thousand island dressing on toasted bun 7.99

Mushroom Swiss Burger grilled your way with sauteed mushrooms, melted swiss cheese on toasted bun 7.99

Bacon Cheddar Burger grilled your way topped with crisp bacon and melted cheddar cheese on toasted bun 7.99

Blue Cheese Burger grilled your way with melted blue cheese piled inside a crisp onion ring on toasted bun 7.99
add bacon for 1.00

Cheese Burger grilled your way with melted american cheese on toasted bun 6.99

Hamburger just one good burger grilled your way served on a toasted bun 6.50



Hand Held Favorites

(available as a wrap upon request, served with chips)

Nathans Hot dog deep fried and served with onions
and relish upon request 3.99 extra toppings coleslaw, chili, kraut, cheese, grilled onions & peppers add 1.00

Steak and Cheese grilled chopped steak with sauteed
onions and peppers on toasted hoagie 7.99 add mushrooms .75

Chicken Sandwich chicken breast filet  grilled,fried or
cajun served on toasted bun 7.99 make it like any burgers for 1

Smoked Pork  5oz of pulled pork served on a toasted bun, choose from our homemade georgia sweet BBQ, spicy mustard BBQ or carolina pig sauce 6.99

Fried Fish Sandwich large filet of alaskan pollock lightly breaded, deep fried served on toasted bun with lettuce and tarter 7.99

Mahi mahi sandwich this tasty fish can be grilled, fried or cajun style served on toasted bun with lettuce, tomato 9.99

Po Boy our hand breaded gator or shrimp deep fried
served on toasted hoagie with lettuce and tomato and homemade tarter or gatoradish sauce 8.99   

Gator Bay Wings

(one ranch/blue cheese per 10 extra .25)

10 Wings 9.50
20 Wings 18.50
30 Wings 27.00
50 Wings 40.00
Celery & Dip 1.50

Wing Flavors

  • Buffalo style (mild- medium- hot)
  • Mango Habenero
  • Sweet BBQ
  • Jamaican jerk
  • Spicy Mustard BBQ
  • Teriyaki
  • Cajun
  • Garlic
  • Sweet Thai
  • Kickin Ranch (hot,med,mild)
  • Carolina Pig
  • Lemon Pepper
  • Gator Bay Dry Rub or our Special Gator Sauce (hot,med,mild), Garlic Parmesan
  • If a specific wing flavor is not listed we will do our best to create it.
  • $.50 charge for mixing flavors per 10.
  • All flats or drums extra $1.00 per 10


(all baskets served with fries and coleslaw)

Southern Gator 11.99

Mahi Mahi 12.99
fried,grilled or cajun

Shrimp 11.99
fried or grilled

Frog Legs 11.99

Chicken Tenders 9.99

Fish Nuggets 9.99

Crab Cakes 12.99


Bottle Beer

Bud Lite Lime
Michelob Lt
Michelob Ultra
Busch Lt
Busch Can
Pbr Can
Miller Lt
Coors Lt
Bud Lt
Sam Adams

Twisted Tea
Angry Orchard
Reds Strawberry
Smirnoff Ice

Draft Beer

Bud Lt
Miller Lt




Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Mountain Dew, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Lemonade, Sweet Iced Tea, Un-sweet Iced Tea

Gator Bay Sauces Now Available

8oz ~ $4.99       16oz ~ $8.99

Hot Buffalo
Med Buffalo
Mild Buffalo
Carolina Pig

Spicy Mustard
Sweet BBQ

Prices subject to change without notice.